Court lets widow of ER creator sue over similarities with The Pitt

A US appeals court has ruled that the medical dramas The Pitt and ER are similar enough for a lawsuit filed by Michael Crichton’s widow to move forward, the Guardian reported. The three‑judge panel issued a unanimous opinion on Wednesday, rejecting an appeal by Warner Bros Television that the two shows are unrelated. By denying the network’s request, the court cleared the way for the case to be heard by a jury in 2027. The decision hinges on the court’s finding of “clear and numerous similarities” between the long‑running, award‑winning series and the newer program. Warner Bros Television had argued for two years that the shows had no connection, but the appellate judges said the evidence did not support that claim. The ruling means the dispute over the alleged copying will now proceed through the courts rather than being dismissed.

Why it matters

The ruling allows the legal challenge over alleged plagiarism to continue, potentially affecting the ownership and profits of a popular medical drama.

Key details

Location

United States · Americas

Reported by

The Guardian

First reported

5 Nov 2026, 10:27 IST

Key names

ER, Pitt, Michael Crichton, Sherri

Section

Entertainment

Sources

This is an independent summary. Read the full, original reporting from the publisher:

• The GuardianThe Pitt and ER are similar enough for Michael Crichton’s widow’s lawsuit to proceed, court rules 5 Nov, 10:27

Read the full story at The Guardian ↗

Spotted an error? Request a correction · How this summary was produced