Doctor barred during Letby trial later served as expert in separate case
The Guardian reported that Professor Peter Hindmarsh, who gave expert evidence that helped secure Lucy Letby’s conviction, was barred from treating patients…
The Guardian reported that Professor Peter Hindmarsh, who gave expert evidence that helped secure Lucy Letby’s conviction, was barred from treating patients during the trial. Hindmarsh was excluded from clinical practice in March 2023 by his employer, University College London Hospitals Trust, while the Letby case was ongoing. After the trial, in which a jury convicted Letby of murdering seven babies, Hindmarsh was instructed as an expert witness in another prosecution. The newspaper said the jury was never informed of his barred status during the Letby proceedings.
The revelation raises questions about the disclosure of a witness’s professional standing in high‑profile criminal trials. Hindmarsh’s involvement in both cases highlights the reliance on specialist testimony in complex medical‑related prosecutions.
Why it matters
The lack of disclosure about Hindmarsh’s barred status could affect the perceived fairness of the Letby trial and future use of expert witnesses.
Key details
- Location
- United Kingdom · Europe
- Reported by
- The Guardian
- First reported
- Key names
- Prof Peter Hindmarsh, Lucy Letby, Letby, Birmingham
- Section
- Health
- Figure cited
- The Guardian revealed this week that Prof Peter Hindmarsh was excluded from clinical practice in March 2023, during the main trial of Letby, by his employer, University College London hospitals trust (UCLH). (The Guardian)
Sources
This is an independent summary. Read the full, original reporting from the publisher:
Read the full story at The GuardianSpotted an error? Request a correction · How this summary was produced
Related Stories
Lawyer urges appeal court to review Letby convictions after expert witness concerns
A lawyer for former paediatric nurse Lucy Letby has asked the Court of Appeal to urgently reconsider her convictions, after The Guardian reported…
Doctor who testified against Lucy Letby was barred from patient care during trial, Guardian finds
The Guardian reported that Prof Peter Hindmarsh, whose evidence helped convict Lucy Letby, was barred from treating patients during the trial over…
Home secretary says she “smells a rat” over Birmingham vulnerable‑housing providers
The Guardian reported that the home secretary has launched an attack on providers of housing for vulnerable residents in her Birmingham…
Birmingham council wins interim ban on flags on public lamp‑posts
The Guardian reported that a high court judge has issued an interim injunction stopping the campaign group Raise the Colours from putting union…
New pill shrinks pancreatic tumours in most trial patients
The Guardian reported that a drug called daraxonrasib has shown promising results in a trial involving patients with advanced pancreatic cancer that…
NSW health warns after three vape users hospitalised with unregistered sedative
Three people in New South Wales were hospitalised after losing consciousness while using certain vape products, according to The Guardian.
Baby born with heart abnormalities ‘didn’t have a chance’ after non-medical free birth, NSW inquest hears
Baby DH, Baby D, Baby R, and Baby B died in the state’s northern rivers region between 2022 and 2024.
Patient discovers therapist notes shared with over 100,000 NHS staff
The Guardian reported that the Information Commissioner’s Office has opened an investigation after a patient learned that her confidential therapist…







