Senior CPS prosecutor cites nonexistent case in high court, raising AI concerns
The Guardian reported that a senior Crown prosecutor cited a legal precedent that does not exist in a high‑court hearing.
The Guardian reported that a senior Crown prosecutor cited a legal precedent that does not exist in a high‑court hearing. Ravinder Dhillon, representing the Crown Prosecution Service, referred to an entirely made‑up case while arguing over whether a child should be prosecuted for raping his younger sister, court documents show. The error, described by the newspaper as “A serious failure”, has added to a growing list of AI‑related mistakes that have appeared in court proceedings. Legal analysts say the incident highlights the risk that artificial‑intelligence tools can generate hallucinated information that is then taken as authoritative. The Guardian noted that the mistaken citation was discovered in the written submissions, prompting renewed scrutiny of how AI‑generated research is used by prosecutors. The episode joins dozens of similar AI errors reported in recent months, prompting calls for tighter safeguards in the justice system.
Why it matters
The incident shows how AI‑generated misinformation can affect legal decisions, potentially undermining the fairness of court proceedings.
Key details
- Location
- United Kingdom · Europe
- Reported by
- The Guardian
- First reported
- Key names
- CPS, AI, AI-related, Ravinder Dhillon
- Section
- Technology
Sources
This is an independent summary. Read the full, original reporting from the publisher:
Read the full story at The GuardianSpotted an error? Request a correction · How this summary was produced
Related Stories
Two men charged with national security offences over RAF Fairford incident
The Crown Prosecution Service said Mohmed Abdulkarim, 24, and Nouman Essghir, 24, were both charged under the National Security Act 2023.
Ryanair eyes pay freezes and crew cuts as fuel costs surge
Ryanair is weighing pay freezes, reducing crew numbers on flights and expanding the use of artificial intelligence to curb a rising fuel bill, the…
National Grid moves to build UK’s largest substation on Teesside
The Guardian reported that National Grid is advancing plans for what would become Britain’s biggest electricity substation on Teesside.
These firms you've never heard of are feeding fears the AI bubble could burst
The amount of debt held by data centres is measured in the tens of billions of pounds.
Apple says it doesn't know when foldable iPhone Duo will return after sell‑out
BBC reported that Apple’s foldable iPhone Duo sold out quickly, with buyers ready to pay $2,000 for the device.
UK cyber agency warns AI-driven malware could target critical sites by 2028
The Guardian reported that the National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) believes AI‑powered malicious software is "highly likely" to be used in hacking…
Legal challenge to Australia's social media ban to start in High Court
The High Court will hear the first major legal challenge to Australia’s world‑leading ban on under‑16s using social media on Tuesday.
Suspected cyber‑attack raises temperatures in European supermarket fridges
The Guardian reported that supermarket fridges and freezers in seven European countries have malfunctioned after a suspected cyber‑attack, with some…